Haley: That's the place where you guys fucked for the first time, right? Zooey: Uh... No. Denise: No, no, no, that was the hot tub in Mexico. Haley: Oh! That's right. Santa Barbara was just oral. Denise: Yeah. Zooey: You guys.

The smile on Peter's face diminishes as he listens to the three ladies talk. Zooey are the other hands smiles... nervously.